The Ultimate Guide to Selecting the Best Cold Brew Coffee Maker

WriterRachel Martin

21 April 2024

The Ultimate Guide to Selecting the Best Cold Brew Coffee Maker

Key Takeaways:

  • The Mueller Cold Brew Coffee Maker ranks highest for its blend of simplicity, convenience, and value.
  • For on-the-go brews, Rockaway Cold Brew Pouches offer a hassle-free and eco-friendly solution.
  • Comprehensive testing of 24 cold brew coffee makers revealed a range of functionality, capacity, and price, emphasizing the importance of personal preferences in material and filter quality.
  • Beyond brewing, cold brew coffee serves versatile culinary uses, from enriching desserts to creating unique cocktails.

Cold brew coffee, with its rich flavor and smooth texture, has become a staple for coffee enthusiasts around the world. Whether you're lounging at home or rushing to work, having the right cold brew maker can transform your coffee routine. After rigorous testing, we're diving deep into what makes the Mueller Cold Brew Coffee Maker a standout choice, alongside the convenience of Rockaway Cold Brew Pouches for those who are always on the move.

The Cold Brew Coffee Maker Showdown

Our extensive coffee maker showdown included a varied selection of 24 cold brew makers, ranging from tried-and-true models to new entrants in the market. We used a consistent coffee blend across all tests to ensure fairness, focusing on brew quality, taste, and ease of cleaning.

Brew and Taste Tests: A Flavorful Journey

The journey began with brew tests, adhering to recommended coffee amounts, grind textures, and steep times. Our goal was to find the perfect balance that would bring out the best in each coffee maker. The taste tests were equally rigorous, comparing the cold brew concentrate undiluted, diluted with cold water, and mixed with a milk product, revealing a wide spectrum of flavors and textures.

Cleaning Up: A Breeze or a Chore?

Post-brew, each coffee maker underwent a cleaning test to assess the ease of disassembly, washing, and reassembly. The ease of disposing of used coffee grounds without creating a mess was a critical factor in our ratings.

Mueller Takes the Lead

Among the contenders, the Mueller Cold Brew Coffee Maker emerged as the clear winner. Its simplicity, ease of cleaning, and reasonable price point set it apart. Notably, its design and brewing capacity cater to both casual drinkers and hardcore coffee aficionados.

On-the-Go Brewing with Rockaway Cold Brew Pouches

Recognizing the modern coffee drinker's mobile lifestyle, Rockaway Cold Brew Pouches offer a compact, eco-friendly solution. Perfect for travel, these pouches simplify the cold brew process without sacrificing quality, making them an editor-loved choice for coffee on the fly.

Material Matters: Glass vs. Plastic

When it comes to selecting a cold brew coffee maker, material plays a significant role. While plastic offers affordability, glass versions provide an aesthetic appeal. However, the choice between glass and plastic comes down to personal preference, as both materials perform equally well in brewing.

Beyond Brewing: The Versatility of Cold Brew

Cold brew coffee isn't just for drinking. Its concentrated flavor makes it ideal for culinary explorations, from enhancing baked goods to crafting innovative cocktails. Plus, cold brew ice cubes offer a creative twist on traditional drinks.

Sustainable Practices: Repurposing Coffee Grounds

Sustainability doesn't end with biodegradable pouches. Used coffee grounds can find a second life in compost bins, as a natural fertilizer for plants, or even as a key ingredient in homemade exfoliating scrubs, showcasing the eco-friendly potential of coffee consumption.

Expert Insights

Our team, led by commerce editor Erin Johnson and senior updates writer Jason Horn, brought a wealth of experience and a keen eye for detail to this comprehensive testing process. Their expertise ensures that our recommendations are not only based on rigorous testing but also on a deep understanding of what makes a great cold brew coffee maker.


Choosing the right cold brew coffee maker is about balancing functionality, personal preferences, and lifestyle needs. Whether you prioritize simplicity and value, like the Mueller Cold Brew Coffee Maker, or need a portable solution like Rockaway Cold Brew Pouches, the perfect cold brew experience is within reach. As we've explored, the world of cold brew coffee extends far beyond the morning cup, offering endless possibilities for culinary creativity and sustainable living.

About the author
Rachel Martin
Rachel Martin
Send email
More posts by Rachel Martin

Rachel Martin is an acclaimed Coffee Makers News Writer, celebrated for her in-depth reviews and barista-level expertise. With an innate passion for coffee culture and a knack for technical detail, Rachel's articles serve as a beacon for coffee enthusiasts navigating the world of home brewing.

Related articles
A Tale of Crime and Compassion: The Case of Nicola Pearce

A Tale of Crime and Compassion: The Case of Nicola Pearce

18 May 2024